Visit the official COVID-19 government website to stay informed: sacoronavirus.co.za

Finding financial well being solutions relevant for employers and their staff

Alexander Forbes has through a series of thought leadership interventions started to change the narrative on retirements and retrenchments in South Africa to a much broader discussion on how collaboration can result in solutions that both employers and their workers need.

This is important because in a world where a rigid regulatory framework often dominates product design thinking, there is a serious risk of losing sight of the most critical issue: How to create solutions that address the critical pain points for clients? By turning the lens of analysis around to the perspective of clients, we have quickly appreciated how easily the retirement industry could be missing the mark.

To demonstrate the power of this co-creation framework, Alexander Forbes transformed its platform for industry thought leadership, the Hot Topics Summit, into a massive case study of live collaboration and co-creation with both clients and with digital innovators from outside the company.

During the past year, Alexander Forbes has been involved in a particularly rewarding social experiment: What if, instead of us creating products for our clients, we co-created and collaborated with them as to what products and services they needed?

To start the exercise, we asked both employees and employers where they believed were the most significant “pain points” in the employment journey. The answer was almost unanimous:

  • the risk of retrenchment and;
  • the reality of retirement…before you are ready

Based on this, the obvious question was what should the retirement industry be doing more effectively if it we are going to address these pain points? The answer we collectively came up with looked like nothing that currently exists. And yet, on reflection, there was nothing we all developed that didn’t seem intuitively obvious.

Through this approach, we have begun to talk about co-creating solutions clients need, which represents a new model for the next generation of product development.

The first step has been to change the narrative so that we think differently about the problem we are trying to solve. This may seem like an unusual starting point but it was fundamental to making sure that we all started to think differently. We had to stop using the terms “retirement” and “retrenchment”. Both those terms seemed to suggest something terminal.

If we were going to be effective in guiding employees through these transitions so that they could go on to be ready, resilient and resourced, we need everyone to think of the problem as simply solving for that period of a person’s life where they would no longer have the underpinning of an employer. Once we make that mind shift, the solutions we contemplate become, by necessity, far broader.

On another level, the narrative change has also made employers think differently. One of the more encouraging outcomes is that employers have begun to appreciate that they have responsibility to the broader South African society of ensuring that employees who leave their protection would:

  • go on to continue to be productive contributors to South African society, or
  • be well insulated from social and economic implosion

We have achieved that by sharing with them several insights that came out of our research:

1. Increasing longevity isn’t about saving for a longer retirement but making people more productive for longer.

At the South African Digital Economic Summit 2019, Dr George Freidman made the point that if human beings were living longer – and they are – then we needed to focus on developing ways to make them productive contributors to the broader economy for longer. As we pointed out in Benefits Barometer 2018, when the UK reframed the costs of caring for the aged against the value they could add to the economy after retirement, they found that older people were making a net contribution of R683 billion … and this was expected to grow to R1 314 billion by 2030.

2. The “secret sauce” for economic growth? Know-how

As Riccardo Hausmann highlighted in his impassioned plea to South African policymakers, if entrepreneurship and the growth of small to medium-sized business were the real workhorses of job creation, the “secret-sauce” of sustainable growth in these business is know-how. With skills and experience at a premium, South Africa desperately needs to find ways to re-introduce those valuable assets that may be potentially lost through retirement and retrenchment. The multiplier effect for job creation of such an exercise would be significantly greater than youth training programmes.

The second step has been to ensure that everyone in the design sprint forms an emotional connection to what happens to people when they through these transitions. This was achieved by conducting workshops with over 2 500 employers, HR teams, employees and members who were near to retirement. The aim was to find out how they would be impacted if they were required to take early retirement with immediate effect. We also wanted to find out how resilient would they be to such a shock.

The questions asked covered topics that went well beyond simple financial resourcing. We delved into issues of health, family obligations, support networks, fall-back options, skill redeployment and alternative income generation.

What emerged was that the impact of early retirement or retrenchment goes far beyond the financial issues and gets right to the heart of what it is that makes us all feel human – a sense of connectedness.

Two things occur at retirement and retrenchment.

  1. The employee no longer benefits from the very thing that made them feel human: daily acknowledgement of their existence and value from colleagues and friends in the workplace.
  2. The workplace no longer benefits from the employee’s experience and skill set.

What goes under-appreciated is that these events can be potentially traumatic on both sides. What it does mean, though, is that before we can even begin to think about helping people with financial planning or developing a further source of income, we need to make sure that they have the emotional stamina to make the transition smoothly.

And it has become evident that we need to go significantly beyond financial advice, which is an important point policymakers should seriously consider. There is also need for a holistic, integrated solution that recognises that individuals have different needs which should be addressed. Importantly, we should acknowledge that this requires new concepts that currently do not exist in the conventional advice framework being applied to these two issues of retirement and retrenchment.

 

 



Latest


04 Aug 2020
Advice for insurance entrepreneurs

“Being battle hardened is what makes you hungry for success. Growing up in a house where your parents can’t cover…

Advice for insurance entrepreneurs

“Being battle hardened is what makes you hungry for success. Growing up in a house where your parents can’t cover the school fees and the family car has broken down for the umpteenth time, makes you focus on what you really want to change in your life.” says Alex Simeonides,…

01 Aug 2020
Achieving balance is not as easy as 60/40

By: Tumi Loate: Investment Team Member, 36ONE Asset Management A simple and traditional balanced portfolio, which allocates 60% to equities…

Achieving balance is not as easy as 60/40

By: Tumi Loate: Investment Team Member, 36ONE Asset Management A simple and traditional balanced portfolio, which allocates 60% to equities and 40% to bonds (a 60/40 allocation) irrespective of the cycle, has produced more than satisfactory returns for global investors over the last two decades. Importantly, however, these returns have…

01 Aug 2020
2020 – a rollercoaster ride

By: James Klempster, CFA, Director of Investment Management, Momentum Investments How to sum up 2020 so far?  A rollercoaster is…

2020 – a rollercoaster ride

By: James Klempster, CFA, Director of Investment Management, Momentum Investments How to sum up 2020 so far?  A rollercoaster is probably the best way to describe it; both from an emotional perspective but also in terms of what the markets have been up to. Over the first quarter, market participants went…

30 Jul 2020
Income protection could be the best investment you ever make

According to the recent Stanlib Savings Report 2020, Covid-19 has highlighted how unprepared South Africans are for unforeseen financial shocks…

Income protection could be the best investment you ever make

According to the recent Stanlib Savings Report 2020, Covid-19 has highlighted how unprepared South Africans are for unforeseen financial shocks – and left without a steady income flow, many have had to dip into long-term savings to fund day-to-day expenses. Part of the reason is that South Africans tend to…


Top stories


10 Apr 2020
When the going gets tough, farmers are on familiar territory

South African farmers are old hands at adapting to uncertain and daunting circumstances, and our local agricultural industry has proved…

When the going gets tough, farmers are on familiar territory

South African farmers are old hands at adapting to uncertain and daunting circumstances, and our local agricultural industry has proved to be most enterprising in acclimatising to challenges as they arise.

13 Apr 2020
Investors should keep a reasonable investment allocation outside of SA

MoneyMarketing asked Roland Gräbe, the head of Tailored Fund Portfolios at Old Mutual Wealth, about offshore investments in the COVID-19…

Investors should keep a reasonable investment allocation outside of SA

MoneyMarketing asked Roland Gräbe, the head of Tailored Fund Portfolios at Old Mutual Wealth, about offshore investments in the COVID-19 environment and what form a global market recovery will take.

13 Apr 2020
SA’s Proposed Covid-19 Disaster Management Tax Relief

The National Treasury recently issued the draft Disaster Management Tax Relief Bill (Bill) for public comment by 15 April. The…

SA’s Proposed Covid-19 Disaster Management Tax Relief

The National Treasury recently issued the draft Disaster Management Tax Relief Bill (Bill) for public comment by 15 April. The draft Bill, together with its explanatory memorandum, provides clarity with regards the tax relief measures President Cyril Ramaphosa announced on 23 March.

11 Apr 2020
Finding investment opportunities among the many COVID-19 risks

With many countries around the world in lockdown as they try to contain the spread of the COVID-19 virus, the…

Finding investment opportunities among the many COVID-19 risks

With many countries around the world in lockdown as they try to contain the spread of the COVID-19 virus, the global economy is facing an unprecedented situation of balancing health against financial livelihoods.