Today, PwC published its wish list for this week’s MTBPS:
Finance Minister Tito Mboweni will deliver his maiden Medium-Term Budget Policy Statement (MTBPS) to Parliament on October 24th. Although most of the medium-term fiscal planning ahead of this event would have been completed before Minister Mboweni was appointed to his new job on October 9th, the new finance minister will now be the face of the fiscus during trying economic times.
South Africa was in a technical recession during the first half of 2018, and its business cycle is in the longest downward phase since records started in 1945. Data from the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) indicated that the local economy was in its 58thstraight month of below-trend activity growth during September.
The MTBPS makes adjustments to national expenditure, estimates of income, taxation laws and relevant administrative processes when necessary. It is also an opportunity for the finance minister to announce adjustments that will have an influence on the South African economy and its consumers, either with immediate effect or, as is most often the case, effective in the next fiscal year.
South Africans are looking to Minister Mboweni this month to bolster their personal finances, job prospects, and the economy as a whole. To achieve this, the finance minister would need to make announcements on several key topics.
These include 1) a revised list of zero-rated value-added tax (VAT) consumer goods, 2) plans to lower record-high fuel prices, 3) the reprioritisation of fiscal spending under the government’s economic stimulus and recovery plan, 4) incentives to stimulate employment creation following the Jobs Summit, and 5) the proposed Infrastructure Fund.
1) Revised zero-rated VAT consumer goods
In May, an independent panel commenced a review of the list of zero-rated VAT items. Although the panel has delivered a report with relevant recommendations and Parliament’s Standing Committee on Finance has also received submissions, the finance minister has yet to make a formal indication on when (and what) changes will be implemented.
Following public submissions, the independent panel recommended the addition of white bread, school uniforms, sanitary products and nappies to the zero-rated list. Subsequent to this, the Standing Committee on Finance heard submissions in favour of adding certain chicken products as well. The National Treasury will need to weigh the benefit to the poor against the expected loss in VAT revenue.
2) Plans to lower record-high fuel prices
Secondly, and also intimately tied to household finances, the MTBPS needs to address the issue of record-high fuel prices. The Department of Energy indicated earlier that it cannot make adjustments to taxes currently forming part of wholesale and retail fuel prices, as these were adopted by Members of Parliament (MPs) when they signed off on the 2018/19 fiscal budget.
A task team made up of officials from the National Treasury and Department of Energy have for several months been working on a strategy to reduce the impact of sharply rising fuel prices on South African households and businesses. They have also requested input from the petroleum industry on the matter. With another fuel price increase expected in November, their work needs to bare fruits.
3) Reprioritisation of fiscal spending
Thirdly, while Minister Mboweni is facing pressure on tax revenues (even before relief is given from a VAT and fuel tax perspective), he also needs to recalibrate planned national expenditure. President Cyril Ramaphosa promised, as part of the economic stimulus and recovery programme, the “reprioritisation of public spending to support job creation”.
The President envisioned spending towards activities “that have the greatest impact on economic growth, domestic demand and job creation, with a particular emphasis on township and rural economies, women and youth”. At the same time, he pledged that this reprioritisation “will take place within the current fiscal framework and in line with the normal budgetary process”. The balancing act between fiscal restraint and maximum job and growth impact is a substantial challenge facing Minister Mboweni from the outset of his tenure.
4) Incentives to stimulate employment creation following the Jobs Summit
Fourthly, a statement released after the recent Jobs Summit committed the government to financial and other obligations in the quest to increase employment creation. For example, government, together with big business and organised labour, agreed that the existing employment tax incentive encouraging youth employment will be extended for a further 10 years.
Other pledges for which fiscal funds would need to be allocated include a facility for the industrial sector to access finance at preferential rates, a guarantee facility to extend the term of financing provided to industrial projects, a R1.5 billion smallholder farmer support fund, and a R1.5 billion township enterprise support fund.
5) Infrastructure Fund
Fifthly, the MTBPS will need to lay the groundwork for President Ramaphosa’s new infrastructure fund. In a speech on September 21st detailing his economic stimulus and recovery programme, the President announced the establishment of this fund, aimed at “unlocking the potential to create more jobs on a large scale”.
The President noted that the fund “will fundamentally transform our approach to the rollout, building and implementation of infrastructure projects”. The fiscus will contribute R400 billion to the Infrastructure Fund over the medium term. The hope is that this investment will attract additional resources from developmental finance institutions, multilateral development banks, and private lenders and investors.
These five elements will be important in supporting household finances and employment creation over the short to medium term. However, Minister Mboweni has inherited a precarious fiscal situation that will make it difficult to find money for these pledges while also keeping ratings agencies happy with regards to rising public debt. In light of this, the MTBPS will be highly anticipated.
Article by Christie Viljoen, PwC Strategy& Economist